Mon 20 Mar 2006
When I teach creative non-fiction, I try to get my pet peeves out in the open right at the beginning. I act as bossy as possible and exaggerate to make my point. For lack of anything interesting to say, I here present my bossy writing tips, exactly as I share them with students. Of course, none of them apply to you, my most admirable fellow bloggers. And there is no reason you should listen to me, either. But it might be fun to think about how lucky you are not to be my student.
[UPDATE: I have decided to put the Mister’s comment in the body of this post because it deftly breaks every single rule in a mere 36 words. Good job decimating the language, Mister! Extra credit to other readers: Can you spot all the egregiousness in his comment?
“Seemingly, its just very corroborated that your a very nice, savvy and judicious preceptor whose students are very much luckier then there ever likely to infer. And thats why you should always listen to your elders.” ]
1. Excessive Use of Big Vocabulary Words: I know it’s tempting. But don’t do it! Multi-syllabic words do not contribute to an impression of intelligence when they are not the right words. They can obscure your meaning, prevent a reader from connecting with your work, or even mislead. Intelligent writing is, above all things, precise. Compare:
“To conquer fear is the beginning of wisdom.” — Bertrand Russell.
Now, my thesaurus version:
“To aggress and magnificently triumph over hysteria is the genesis and commencement of what has been heretofore known, and will henceforth be known, as sagaciousness.”
Which one sounds smarter? You’re right — the first one. Which one is more accurate? You’re right again– the first one. Keep things simple when you can.
2. Moralizing. Opening and/or closing paragraphs do not need to contain a moral lesson, such as “hard work pays off” or “keep trying even if you fail at first” or “family relationships are important.” For an essay to be worthy of existing, all it needs is to be interesting. Of course, interesting essays often contain life lessons. However, those lessons are part of the fabric of the essay, revealed in details and events, rather than tacked on at the end. Instead of using a moral assertion to end your work, try using an image that seems significant– you will likely find that the moral comes through elegantly without being stated.
3. Overwriting. Sentences which are full of repetition and piled-up adjectives suffer from overwriting. These characteristics indicate that you don’t trust your reader to be smart enough to figure it out. Readers resent this. They think, “I got the idea in the first three words, why does the author keep going on and on? I’m not stupid!” This admonishment is a little tricky, because I am always after students to add more detail to essays; but the key is to choose appropriate details. In many cases, less is more.
Example of overwriting: The tears that came welling up from her big, round, blue eyes were like beautiful pearls cascading from her eyes.
Better: Her tears shone in the lamplight.
4. Padding sentences. Avoid the following words, which add little to a sentence: just, really, very, nice, so, a lot, practically, seemingly. Most of these words are used to add intensity; try to replace them with more specific nouns, verbs, and adjectives.
Example of padded sentence: I was just so happy to get a really nice present; it was really big and very exciting, a lot more than I had expected.
Better: I couldn’t stop clapping when I got the present. It was the size of a washing machine and wrapped in fluorescent green paper.
5. Basic Grammar and Spelling Errors. Get your facts straight on your/you’re, their/there/they’re, then/than, its/it’s.
Correct usage of each:
Eat your peas.
I hear you’re the King of Spain.
We took their breakfast cereal when they weren’t looking.
He’s headed to the landfill? Why would he want to go there?
They’re full of big ideas.
I ate my pomegranate and then I went to the water park.
You have much bigger hair than I do.
We annoyed the dog when we combed its fur.
I’m going out because it’s Saturday night.
March 20th, 2006 at 3:21 pm
Seemingly, its just very corroborated that your a very nice, savvy and judicious preceptor whose students are very much luckier then there ever likely to infer. And thats why you should always listen to your elders.
March 20th, 2006 at 6:02 pm
I know I asked for these tips of yores, but I’m suddenly more self-conscience than is my normal modus operandi. Might you refrain from reading past posts previously written in my blog? I promise to rectify the aforementioned problem areas heretofore, but I can’t realistically return to the passed to retroactively re-interpret those errors which have occurred in the passed. I don’t want to be sitting in a pot calling the kettle black, or going from the frying pan into the fire!
March 20th, 2006 at 11:57 pm
How shall I begin?
“Since the beginning of time, mankind has tried to express himself in writing. In today’s society . . .”
OR
“Webster’s dictionary defines ‘blog’ as . . .”
Erin, i LOVED your post. How do you feel about the increasingly ubiquitous, redundant “particular,” as in “this particular film”? That’s one of my current pet peeves. (There are many, many more where that one came from . . .)
March 21st, 2006 at 11:41 am
Oops. I would do well to keep No. 4 in mind.
March 21st, 2006 at 12:10 pm
You guys kill me. I can tell from your comments who reads student papers for a living (or part of it).
Mike, in the passed I have not consciencely noticed your breaking any of my rules. So you are in the clear! Good job bringing up those two spelling errors, I am going to add them to my handout fo sho.
Tara, I don’t get many “academic” papers in my current line o work so I’m spared a lot of the nonsense you describe, at least for the time being! WHEW. But maybe YOU could do a post on your pet peeves? Then I can laugh my guts out and think, “there but for the grace of God go I.”
March 22nd, 2006 at 2:55 am
Have you read the book _Eats, Shoots & Leaves: The Zero Tolerance Approach to Punctuation_?
I think it would be a very satisfying experience for you.